dixie chicks are just retarded

katekate permalink | categories: diversity, education, tampa
by kate @ 9:37 am

More crazy conversations from the classroom…

One of my all-time best students, we’ll call him Kenny, and I started at Superior High School at the same time. I had him his freshman and sophomore year, missed his junior year because I tried out two other local high schools, and returned this year to see him graduate.

Kenny, my favorite little redneck, is a delight.

“Ms. Robinson, the principal took my confederate flag off my truck!”

“Did he?”

“Yeah, how’s that for unfair? Says it offended people. Did you complain Ms. Robinson? Was it you?”

“It was not me,” I said, laughing. “You and I have talked about this. I’ve tried to tell you the confederate flag is a racist symbol that made its comeback a hundred years after the Civil War ended in response to civil rights legislation of the 1960s. It was a message to black Southerners that they would not be considered legitimate members of society. It’s a disgrace. But no, Kenny, I didn’t complain about your flag.”

“Southern pride, Ms. Robinson. It’s all about southern pride.”

“Let me ask you a question, Kenny.”

“Anything.”

“Do you like the Dixie Chicks?”

“No way!”

“Why not?”

“They’re traitors! They trashed our country and don’t care about our soldiers. They are on Saddam’s side!”

“The Dixie Chicks said twelve words, Kenny. ‘We are ashamed the President of the United States is from Texas.’ And for that, they are traitors. For that, they deserve to have their albums burned and for that, they deserve no career of any kind. I see. Then explain something to me, please.

“Explain how you can proudly wave the emblem of a movement that sought to remove the South from the United States altogether and Form. Another. Country.

“A movement that sought to enslave human beings.

“A movement that took up arms against an American President and his soldiers.

“Cause if that ain’t traitorous, jeez, Kenny, I don’t know what is.”

(Long pause.)

“C’mon Kenny, explain it to me.”

“I don’t know, Ms. Robinson. The Dixie Chicks are just retarded.”

Don’t kid yourself. Kenny is still thinking about what I said.

***cross-posted at Out in Left Field***


Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Fark
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Live
  • Technorati
Tags: , ,

Possibly related posts (auto-generated)

13 Responses to “dixie chicks are just retarded”

  1. Rachel* Says:

    It’s really wonderful the way you love your job so much. I disagree with almost everything you say about your personal life, but you seem pretty unbeatable in that classroom.

  2. Bob Says:

    I guess Rachel is not a fan of Brazilian waxes.

  3. C.W. Says:

    You’re holding political debates with little kids. Good job, Kate. Hope you’re proud of yourself. Based on your missives, you are!

  4. kate Says:

    Thanks Rachel*. You sound an awful lot like my mom, ya know. Close my eyes and I’m right back at the Thanksgiving table trying to choke down a goblet of wine. Uncanny. Seriously.

    And I wouldn’t call 17 and 18 year olds, “little kids” - but maybe they are to a old fart.

  5. dcdave Says:

    Way to outsmart a high school kid =)

  6. DAF Says:

    She’s trying to get this “kid” to think. Why are you putting her down? I think what you did is wonderful.

  7. Sandy Says:

    Yeah. What DAF said. And I still say CW needs to take some pills. Has he EVER said anything positive?

  8. Sandy Says:

    …or she (but I doubt it).

  9. Jacob Varghese Says:

    Kids need to be engaged at any age.
    I think it’s good to challenge them and get them thinking about different viewpoints.

  10. lubbockorleaveit Says:

    I wanted to get everyone’s feedback on a new site we have built. It takes the contraversy surrounding the dixie chicks and does some good with it by giving those with strong feelings the opportunity to express their opinions and help charity at the same time. Check out the site. This is not an advertisement. I just wanted to get some opinions on this site from those with strong opinions.
    http://www.Lubbockorleaveit.com
    goto: http://www.lubbockorleaveit.com
    Our Mission
    We shall raise a great deal of money for charity by creating a fun, exciting and informative forum centered on the public’s opinion regarding statements made by the Dixie Chicks.
    Ok, everyone, it’s time to put your money where your mouth is! For the minute cost of a matinee movie ticket, Lubbockorleaveit.com gives you the opportunity to help us raise money for deserving charities by voting on whether or not you agree or disagree with statements made by the Dixie Chicks. Your entire donation, net only of credit cards fees, will be delivered to the appropriate charities. Your vote will be applied to the state of your choice and will be viewable in our interactive map. Try it out and help our charities.
    Home for Our Troops Scholarship fund ( http://www.homesforourtroops.org/site/PageSer... )
    The Freedom Alliance ( http://www.freedomalliance.org/ )

  11. Sticks of Fire: a Tampa blog » Blog Archive » trailer pinellas park Says:

    [...] But not to worry, Ms. Bailey-Snook. Some of our Tampa residents are very fluent in redneck, too. Dang, we even got students that proudly display your city’s unofficial flag. [...]

  12. Dr BLT Says:

    I was merely making a musical statement about how I thought the Grammys were rigged in favor of the Dixie Chicks due to politics.

    I really didn’t imagine this song would take off on the internet like it has.

    Playin’ Politics With the Dixie Chicks
    Dr BLT
    words and music by Dr. BLT (c) 2007
    http://www.drblt.net/music/DixieChicks.mp3

    So I want to thank all of you who have made this possible and offer you another opportunity to download the song for free while its still available.
    Thanks for making the song such a collosal success!

  13. southerngal Says:

    You are WRONG!!!! The Confederate Flag is not a symbol of slavery!! In fact contrary to most beliefs, the Civil War wasn’t even about slavery, and President Lincoln was FOR slavery!!!! In fact the North had WAY more slaves than the South ever did!!!!

Leave a Reply